In studying
culture and diversity, in chapter six of the Woolfolk text, I wondered if some
sort of disclaimer or ‘proceed with caution,’ sign should have been placed
meticulously across the chapter. I have
always wondered if there was any data that displayed the cultural implications
of students in the classroom. I have
worked in schools that were predominantly Caucasian and I currently work in a
school that is predominantly African American.
What I have learned in both settings is that there can be stereotype
threats apparent in every classroom if we don’t first ascertain what our
judgments are about people of our own race and others.
While working in
a school where 99% of the teachers were Caucasian a few things stood out. Sometimes when I spoke with other teachers,
even one’s I’d never met, they would consistently use slang or speak to me in
an informal way, even if I’d just seen them have conversations with teachers
that they knew very well that were very professional.
I also noticed
that there were times when Caucasian teachers would set different expectations
for the African American students than they did the children of different
races. They made assumptions about their
home life and economic status that influenced
the way they spoke to them or even their classroom expectations. The teacher
was in her second year teaching, she was from a predominantly Caucasian area,
had gone to a predominantly Caucasian high school, and went on to attend a
predominantly Caucasian university. She
confessed to me that she had never had an African American friend, and had very
little experience with other cultures. I
realized that we’d both made some assumptions that weren’t true. I assumed that everyone has had diverse experiences
in their lives. I assume that when you
are of a certain age, that you’ve met and mingled with all sorts of people in
all sorts of environments. This is not
the case. The young teachers that I’d
encountered had a very limited worldview.
This group of teachers and myself did something that I find profound and
it’s something that I hope to bring to my own teaching. We talked openly about race and culture and
assumed good intentions on all of our behalf.
They were experiencing a sense of cultural fear, but they were open to
hearing and reflecting on the way they taught their African American boys and
make changes if necessary. I talked
openly about the way that I felt when they talked to me, and I asked them to
think about how they made their students feel when they didn’t set the same
expectation, or ‘dumbed’ down their language when they spoke one on one to
those students. To this day, I remain
friends with many of these ladies and our relationship has evolved into true
friendships, I believe because of the courage that we had to have those early
conversations.
I see similar
circumstances in my current school setting.
Students who have never had any interactions with people of different
races are slow to warm to their teachers. Some of the students will become extremely
defensive when a teacher of another race redirects them. I’ve even had conversations with students
about teachers, ‘not liking them, because they don’t like Black people.’ The most successful teachers at my school, no
matter what the race, have confidence and self-awareness. They don’t let race or culture interfere with
the goal of seeing our students achieve.
Our most successful teachers don’t seem to care whether or not they are
seen as White, Black, Hispanic or Asian, they treat the students with respect
and expect the same in return. They don’t shy away from cultural
questions. I remember having a
conversation with one of my colleagues about how obsessed the female students
were with her hair. I told her that they
thought that she and her hair were beautiful, but she might want to bring in
some diverse magazines that the students could look through in their down time
so that they could see how beautiful that their own hair was. I think that it is so important to be aware
of the ethnic cultures of our students because there are so many teachable
moments that we can take advantage of when we least expect it.
I think that it’s
very difficult to define an individual. As
I read through Chapter six on culture and diversity, you notice you don’t find
a chapter called, “ how to teach working class African American students, or
“how to teach, lower class, Catholic, Asian students”. This week we studied the connections between
poverty and school achievement, how are biases effect our teaching and
developing culturally relevant pedagogy.
Establishing cultural competence as a teacher helps us and our students
grow inside and outside of our classrooms.
Hi Beverly,
ReplyDeleteVery informative blog. I enjoyed the cultural diversity experiences you have shared with us. While I attended a multi-cultural high school, I realized when we did the diversity project with Mrs. Webster-Moore, that she was the first African American teacher that I had ever had. I had never thought about that before and honestly found that jarring. I wish I could have been in on the conversations that you and your co-workers had together. Every time we have the opportunity to make ourselves less ignorant concerning one another, we need to take advantage of it. Hopefully during this next year we will be blessed enough to learn more than just academics from each other.
Beverly, I think it's great that you were able to be open and honest about race and ethnicity with your co-workers. I think that most people want to do the right thing, but many just don't have the life experiences and/or exposure to diversity to know what the right thing is. Some think that the best strategy is to just be "color blind," but that's not what we want either. We all want to be seen and noticed for who we are. Your policy of just getting it out there and discussing it honestly is what's needed. Thanks for sharing this.
ReplyDeleteHey Beverly!
ReplyDeleteI too have witnessed the "dumbed down" language. It's funny, because if you have ever watched "Everybody hates Chris", you will notice they have a Caucasian teacher "Dumbing down" her language when she talks to Chris (African American boy in the TV show). They make it as a joke in the show, but it is true to life. Some teachers may or may not be aware that they are doing it, but the child they do it to and the students around, see's it. Its not a comfortable situation at all.